Riddle Me Thisis a recurring segment on Comedy Bang! Bang!. Ben Schwartz introduced this game to the show informally in 263: Hollywild, though he seems to not care for the game (and not remember "inventing" it) in 354: Solo Bolo: Dos Lo, he still doesn't like or remember the game in Solo Bolo Trolo.
The theme tune for Riddle Me This was originally Prince's "Partyman" from Batman. It was mentioned that it is actually a theme for the Joker and it would make more sense if it was a Riddler theme. After that, Scott began singing the Riddler theme a capella. The theme is now a clip from 284: A Thrilling CBB Adventure Hour of Croach the Tracker from Thrilling Adventure Hour (Mark Gagliardi) simply rapping "Riddler." In the clip, Scott comments that it is a good song.